I know this makes me a bad fan but I read so much stuff and get so lost in "hey this is neat" following this link and that story, that I lose track of what I've commented on or not. OTOH I've lost track of the number of fics or metas I've reread and discovered I commented months ago - and now have a slightly different take on the subject, or had no memory of commenting in the first place.

But yes, I liked it very much - much more so than I did the episode, because it's much more real and complex and true to who Willow was right at that moment.