I honestly like them, I promise. I voted for 1 and 15. I was totally sure for 15 - not only because of the font but also because the moment you choose which is so poignant for Buffy and a Buffyfan - same though about icon 1. They are really gorgeous icons.
I also voted a Spike icon - I don't know who's the author - because he's my baby and the icon was portraying him beautifully, but I had to choose between that and a stunning Willow one and it was hard. People, you're skilled!