It's probably one of the worst BTVS episodes for me, but all in all..it's still Buffy.

Thank you for explaining - the MOTW is the weakest aspect but that's always true of MOTW eps. I still find the generalized amount of hate it gets over and over puzzling. I remembered the episode as charming and funny and I just rewatched yesterday it and still enjoyed it. Whereas there are other episodes that are far worse IMO, or at best forgettable: The Witch, Inca Mummy Girl (my candidate for worst, possibly), Puppet Show (dull), Bad Eggs, the rage and headache inducing As You Were.

I have to say cat5 is my favorite.

Thank you! That one is definitely one of my favorites - one I knew I had to include come hell or high water. I had a version with the text "we're doomed" but it just didn't work - the image said it all. I'm not great with text if you hadn't noticed *lol*

I also loved the text in personification

Except maybe that one, I do like - at least in concept. I suppose it would have been more interesting to have part of the text obscured by the cup and let the viewer fill in the gap in their minds? *ponders*

And AC 5 is one of my faves - it and AC1 were two of my "I have to include this come hell or high water" icons. I always want to create a visually coherent AC set but usually just end up cherry picking among all my alts.