#12 is one of my favorite icons I've ever made - and it was one of the simplest. Those are often my favorites, the ones that "make themselves" hardly any "special effects, just a little tinting and brightening, then the frame. It's the two fonts that are the 'special effect' to serve the mood and expression, and somehow it came together beautifully in that one.

I honestly don't remember which ones I voted for personally except #1 (me and my old brain...) - young Willow and Buffy at the Espresso Pump, how cute is that?

And yes, I will definitely trot out the entire set.

I hope you don't find them tiresome - I tend to do several icons using a single ideal, image or text; sometimes I just like them all equally and can't decide! (That's why I need Ryan to hold my hand, which he did brilliantly.)