Yup to Anya! It's one of my very first icons, though not one I made myself. So much love for Giles & Anya! I agree though; I like him with Joyce too, or with Jenny. I have to say though that Giles with one of the scoobies tends to seriously creep me out. I can usually see where shippers are coming from even if I don't agree but not in that case!

It's not a rules-verse fic as far as I remember; let me look and see what I can find. Lilah was a major character IIRC.